Food /Fort Greene /Pizza

On the MUSEENYC M ListOn the MUSEENYC M ListThe M List — one we'd cross the city for, and keep going back to. See the list →

9.4 / 10

Joe & Sal's Pizzeria

Thin, well done, minimal flop — Myrtle Avenue pizza made by people who clearly care.

MUSEENYC · August 18, 2026

Where
353 Myrtle Ave, Fort GreeneOpen in Google Maps ↗
Price
$$
Order this
Plain slice · Sicilian

Going? Tell them MUSEENYC sent you. It's not a discount and there's nothing to redeem — we just want them to know where you heard it.

You can tell this pizza is made with love. Thin, with minimal flop, and a robust flavour that holds up on the walk. There are plenty of styles on offer, and a full menu at certain hours if you want more than a slice.

What to know

Ask for it well done — that’s how this pizza is best. Counter service, and Fort Greene Park is a five-minute walk north if you’d rather sit down with it.

353 Myrtle Ave, Fort Greene. Directions in Google Maps ↗