MUSEENYC / Neighborhoods / City Island

City Island

1 place to eat.

See it on the map →

Where to eat in City Island

Rating TBDJohnny's ReefSeafood$$Fried seafood on paper plates at the end of City Island, facing open water.

Cuisines in City Island: Seafood

City Island questions, answered

Where should I eat in City Island?

First on our list in City Island is Johnny's Reef — Fried seafood on paper plates at the end of City Island, facing open water. We list 1 place in City Island and have not scored it yet.

Is City Island worth visiting?

Yes — City Island has 1 place on MUSEENYC right now: 1 place to eat. Everything on this page was chosen by people who live in New York, and nobody pays to be included.