Food / Lower East Side / Pizza

On the MUSEENYC M ListOn the MUSEENYC M ListThe M List — one we'd cross the city for, and keep going back to. See the list →

9.2 / 10

Scarr's Pizza

Skip the famous takeout line: walk inside, get a table, and have great pizza with a drink from the bar.

MUSEENYC

The neon Scarr’s Pizza sign in the window at night, with a crowd waiting on the sidewalk outside on Orchard Street.
Where
35 Orchard St, Lower East Side Open in Google Maps ↗
Price
$$$
Website
www.scarrspizza.com

You will probably see the line before you see the sign. Know this: the line is for takeout only. Walk right past it, go inside to the host, and get a seat.

Then sit back and do it properly. The pizza is the reason the line exists, and inside you get it at a table with a curated drink from the bar instead of folded on the sidewalk.

What to know

On Orchard Street, where the Lower East Side meets Chinatown. Scarr’s moved here from across the street in 2023, into a bigger space with a full bar and a dine-in menu.

Going? Tell them MUSEENYC sent you. It's not a discount and there's nothing to redeem — we just want them to know where you heard it.

Scarr's Pizza, in short

Where is Scarr's Pizza?

Scarr's Pizza is at 35 Orchard St, in Lower East Side, New York City.

How much does Scarr's Pizza cost?

Scarr's Pizza is expensive; expect roughly $35–75 a head.

35 Orchard St, Lower East Side. Directions in Google Maps ↗